Branching, Merging, Remove/Add

Branches and Dates

A variety of CVS commands (diff, update, checkout, update -j, maybe others) would like to be able to specify both a branch to operate on and a date to select a revision within that branch. There should be a consistent syntax for this which works across all commands. Here is one initial patch and revised version for CVS diff. Plus another from another author. All of these need test cases and documentation.

Death Support for Directories

CVS should be able to handle adding and deleting directories as well as it handles adding and deleting files. Here is a very preliminary patch.

Adding and Removing Files

Here is a case where CVS will bogusly print "Up-to-date check failed" when it should be doing something much more sensible.

Here is a case involving a remove, where CVS seems to not be handling conflicts correctly.

Diff Library

Here is a bug report concerning some of CVS's merging behavior.

CVS Annotate and Branches

Currently CVS annotate does not use your current branch; you must explicitly specify -r to annotate a branch. Here is a slightly more detailed discussion.

Branch Naming

If you have a branch named "foo", you can already refer to the revisions on that branch as "foo.1", "foo.2", and so on. The output from "cvs log" should perhaps use those names, which would reduce the standard need to tell new users "don't pay attention to the revision numbers".

Somewhat along those lines, "foo.0" could refer to the branchpoint, "foo.-1" could refer to the revision before that, etc. This nomenclature reflects the set of revisions which led up to the head of the "foo" ranch. "foo.0", in particular, would seem to remove the need to tag the branchpoint manually, which is another non-intuitive but currently recommended practice.